My problems with the monotheistic concept of praying for God to do things:
1) If ones believes that the one Deity is all knowing, then why are they asking Them to do things They already know needs done?
Even worse is when people believe their Deity inspired them to ask for it, because then the Deity is asking you do tell Them to do something that They knew needed done but has already actively chosen not to do.
2) Begging one's Deity to do things that They already know about is treating Them like a tyrant who could help out of kindness but would rather get kicks from hearing people beg for it. That is disrespectful, in my view.
3) Asking a supreme Deity to change their way of doing things just for one person is presumptuous and the exact opposite of humility. (
Apparently George Carlin says it funnier than me.) Even asking them to change it for everyone on Earth is presumptuous, as our planet is a
tiny bit of dust in the
grand scheme of the universe.
4) Asking for some things is effectively asking a Deity to override people's free will. Examples would be asking for someone to be saved, or asking for favorable election results (
Huckabee saying "Well, I didn't major in math, I majored in miracles." springs to mind.) If a 'good' Deity could and would do that, we wouldn't be in the messes we are in to begin with.
5) Saying that a Deity answered a prayer insinuates that one believes other people, who prayed but died or lost out anyway, are somehow lesser than them or are less loved by their Deity.
6) In many cases saying a Deity saved someone, or that it was a miracle, takes well deserved respect and thanks away from the police, doctors, military, or others who actually saved the person. If one really believed God was capable of such things, they would take their sick to a priest rather than a hospital. Its hard to ignore that people who do that typically die.
If a monotheist really believes in their Deity, they should never ask for anything. They should simply believe that what is suppose to happen will happen, and spend more time trying to understand why things happen than asking an almighty Deity to change their way of doing things just for them.
Labels: monotheism, prayer, praying, religion